Copy
How Diply.com and Other Websites Are Using Facebook Influencers 
View this email in your browser

Jake Bialer's Take On The Future Of Journalism

 
Was This Email Forwarded To You? Subscribe here: http://eepurl.com/VuLwf
Influencers Partnerships Are Viral Steroids

Diply.com, a viral content site, is the 20th most popular site in the United States with 54 million monthly unique visitors. Globally, they have 120 million monthly unique visitors. This data comes from Quantcast, which directly measures the traffic at Diply.com.  According to a study by Compete.com, commissioned by Diply, Diply became the ”fastest growing website” in history last August.

So what’s going on? How did Diply—which sounds like a web 2.0 version of Dunkaroos—grow into a popular viral media site so rapidly? How does Diply work?
The short answer: influential social media accounts. They’re APlus on steroids, and EPO while throwing a deflated football.

Diply appears to have partnered with hundreds of influential social media accounts, primarily Facebook, but also other social networks such as Twitter and Google+.

Based on an analysis of the post history of the top 1000 celebrity pages and the top 1000 community pages on Facebook from January 2014 through May 2015, they’re not alone.

In fact, a large amount of viral media sites that have seen substantial growth in the last year have grown with significant help through partnerships with influential Facebook accounts unrelated to their brand. It’s not clear exactly how these partnerships work, but the sheer quantity of posts shared from a specific set of sites on unaffiliated influential accounts strongly suggests this sharing isn’t random and there is some sort of working arrangement in place.

There’s LittleThings.com, right behind Diply, with 72 million global monthly unique vistors. OmgFacts.com (15M uniques) and Dose.com (35M uniques), whose founder was profiled in the New Yorker earlier this year, make good use of influencer accounts. As do UpRoxx.com, ViralNova.com, TheChive.com, Bustle.com, APlus.com, Matterdome.com, ijreview.com, Distractify.com, TwentyWords.com, BroBible.com, Guff.com, and many more.

Here’s the situation

  1. Consistent production of viral content isn’t hard.  Viral content is still part art, part science, but there are more and more people out there who can consistently produce viral content. To help these people, there is a ton of data on viral content and good tools for navigating it, like BuzzSumo, NewsWhip, and CrowdTangle. Viral sites can learn from other sites and either embed viral content or (for the less ethically inclined) plagiarize it.

  2. Facebook is the biggest social network. If you can get a post to do well on Facebook, then you can reach a large part of the world. Other social networks matter, but Facebook is the most important.

  3. The content matters, but the source does not. If a random page shares an article you like, most people don’t care. Facebook’s business model is based on people liking content from random pages in their feed.

  4. Facebook reach is hard. Even pages with hundreds of thousands of followers struggle to reach people.

  5. If you want a post to reach a large number of people, the best way is to get a lot of influential pages sharing it

  6. There are a large number of pages with a lot of likes that are looking for business opportunities. "I have x-million Facebook followers. How do I monetize it?"

  7. Paying an influencer is worth the price. If paying Facebook pages to post your content is cheaper than Facebook ads and cost per click is less than the lifetime value from each user, then it is worth it. Alternatively, if acquiring a Facebook page is cheaper than Facebook ads, it is also worth it.

Given this situation, the strategy to get a large amount of Facebook traffic is simple: get a large number of influencers to post your content.

This practice doesn’t feel exactly right. This isn’t how Facebook was designed to work, and Facebook’s terms of service specify “Page names and Facebook Web Addresses must accurately reflect Page content. We may remove administrative rights or require you to change the Page name and Facebook Web Address for any Page that fails to meet this requirement.” and “Third-party advertisements on Pages are prohibited, without our prior permission.” Both of these are violated by a lot of these pages. That being said, Facebook doesn’t appear to be enforcing either term. If it actually prohibited third-party advertisements, it would interfere with the practices of a lot of celebrities promoting sponsors and, perhaps, even news organizations promoting sponsored content.   

There are several methods for a media organization to get pages with a lot of likes:
  1. Grow pages with a large amount of likes. Use your own content, random content, whatever works. Just get an audience. You can shift your focus later. People don’t care.

  2. Buy pages with a large number of likes.

  3. Partner with pages that have a large number of of likes. Posting sponsored content on users’ feeds is fundamental to a platform business model.  

Diply, the leader of the sites utilizing influencers, has used a combination of all three methods. Their main page appears to be purchased, given that it originally started off as Different Solutions (posting Egg Carton Christmas Trees back in 2012), but they’ve continued to build it organically with some onsite promotion.

However, their key viral tool is their partners. They have a lot of Facebook partners. Their partners aren’t limited to Facebook. They also partner with influencers on other social networks, including Twitter and Google+.

Each partner seems to have an associated section on their website. For example, the French Facebook page JE T'AIME MAMAN (I love you mom) posts lots of Diply links. Each Diply link is featured in a http://diply.com/je-taime section of their site. In other words, instead of breaking their website up based on topics (sports, business, politics), they break their site up based on viral Facebook pages (George Takei, Oh My God Facts!, and Did You Know?).

Below, I've put together tables showing the accounts that each site appears to be partnering with along with likes, shares, comments, and total number of posts.  Each table is ordered based on the number of posts each partner has made.  Some of these posts may be organic, particularly those that come from accounts with five or fewer posts, but I suspect a large amount of them are paid. The data in these tables comes from January 2014 through May 2015. I only looked at 2000 accounts: those on the top 1000 celebrity pages and the top 1000 community pages on Facebook. I've tried to delete accounts directly affiliated with each website, but I may have missed some.

 

1. Diply.com


Notice that George Takei drove 6,891,858 likes and 2,117,726 shares! His Facebook account drives a huge of amount of likes to his partners.
 

From

Likes

Shares

Comments

Posts

F.A.C.E (Facil Adiccion al Chisme y Entretenimiento)

291,746

57,537

9,581

1,467

JE T'AIME MAMAN

2,011,089

382,297

112,718

673

Funny Videos

567,207

236,822

40,503

639

Best Vines

126,319

26,664

19,162

546

Architecture & Design

2,129,263

416,084

48,088

494

Humor meets comics

202,597

78,281

12,192

384

Oh My God Facts!

1,057,884

424,282

57,593

366

Real men don't cheat on, lie to, or abuse woman.

135,781

76,301

8,616

288

George Takei

6,891,858

2,117,726

288,323

261

Did You Know

454,294

115,294

24,463

217

Sean Kingston

480,426

81,486

22,335

178

F A C T

126,974

54,263

7,245

166

1,000,000 Pictures

133,027

35,460

6,965

97

Beautiful Amazing World

44,712

12,535

1,788

87

I Love My Dog

326,394

60,241

10,179

84

Lil Jon

198,396

27,649

8,491

72

It was just a dream... Dammit!

53,715

11,319

3,586

64

B.o.B

234,072

31,490

11,611

63

ScienceAlert

480,827

104,570

17,545

60

Cheech and Chong

415,375

135,522

13,483

59

George Lopez

468,392

91,870

13,739

54

Tommy Chong

258,853

79,752

7,323

47

Worldstar Hip Hop

14,716

2,055

1,282

42

Joe Jonas

133,255

4,417

2,145

32

Ludacris

387,953

63,646

21,061

31

Paris Hilton

138,616

4,415

4,792

28

Mike "The Situation"

27,726

4,578

1,046

22

T-Pain

27,659

1,942

812

14

Pretty Ricky

34,298

4,471

811

10

Jeff Dunham

203,335

53,585

6,102

9

The Game

16,329

2,189

1,754

7

Bow Wow

12,969

839

180

5

Jay Sean

3,392

224

100

5

Guns N' Roses

136,112

13,749

2,428

4

Lil Twist

4,223

421

228

4

Gerard Piqué

414,483

3,357

5,110

3

Being Hyper!

1,462

605

35

3

Kick Ass Vines

518

30

19

3

Steve-O

47,210

9,078

1,381

2

Kesha

21,765

794

408

2

Waka Flocka Flame

19,154

3,801

707

2

Soulja Boy Tell Em

14,715

539

138

2

Fantasia

2,191

138

53

2

Kevin Hart

129,991

48,581

18,949

1

Neil deGrasse Tyson

24,735

1,969

377

1

Ronaldo7.net

19,577

316

145

1

WeeklyChris

11,718

262

209

1

Michelle Rodriguez

7,501

30

66

1

Blink-182

6,419

394

136

1

Eva Longoria

4,494

150

73

1

Keri Hilson

501

29

13

1

 

2. LittleThings.com

 

From

Likes

Shares

Comments

Posts

Sun Gazing

2,629,677

1,592,509

187,513

1,403

Being Mommy

4,165,110

1,420,030

126,748

773

I Love My Dog

2,100,223

505,414

90,041

693

George Takei

3,329,902

969,163

148,769

89

Women Get It Free

309,386

171,954

14,736

77

Did You Know

92,213

19,310

4,312

40

George Lopez

292,175

81,026

8,648

19

Cheech and Chong

264,343

77,161

8,665

10

Tommy Chong

150,305

78,007

4,276

6

Zendaya

79,762

6,253

2,405

3

Bow Wow

7,640

1,763

113

1

Joe Jonas

3,733

66

38

1

Power of Positivity

1,177

263

55

1

 

3. Dose.com

From

Likes

Shares

Comments

Posts

YoMama

26,342

6,137

1,104

233

F A C T

92,779

40,355

5,095

138

Did You Know

266,748

48,721

10,041

97

George Takei

989,434

411,984

60,083

39

1,000,000 Pictures

16,126

5,014

815

17

Ludacris

145,048

31,016

7,780

15

B.o.B

28,333

4,500

2,491

13

Bow Wow

18,063

1,281

888

12

Sean Kingston

41,862

6,523

2,557

12

Cheech and Chong

74,619

34,044

6,893

11

Joe Jonas

27,960

675

441

11

2 Chainz

16,189

1,500

738

9

Gucci Mane

11,449

2,996

785

9

The Game

20,382

6,194

2,688

9

George Lopez

38,711

13,578

3,264

7

Lil Twist

5,891

933

300

7

Tommy Chong

50,550

26,577

2,054

6

Jay Sean

3,865

514

146

4

Lil Jon

22,785

2,534

422

4

Being Mommy

11,470

7,688

632

3

Paris Hilton

14,481

1,203

418

3

Beautiful Amazing World

246

56

12

1

Keri Hilson

6,868

842

149

1

Mike Epps

1,766

316

941

1

T-Pain

3,957

1,084

314

1

Timbaland

295

9

11

1

Young Jeezy

14,003

925

461

1

4. UpRoxx.com

 

From

Likes

Shares

Comments

Posts

Did You Know

75,035

14,065

4,079

42

George Takei

677,675

173,280

42,337

18

Cheech and Chong

134,097

42,215

11,384

14

Tommy Chong

110,099

46,686

6,341

9

George Lopez

79,018

14,168

2,224

6

Being Mommy

5,446

718

403

5

Trina

2,560

37

28

4

Keri Hilson

1,975

169

130

3

B.o.B

4,308

464

199

2

Lil Jon

7,059

1,200

507

2

Sean Kingston

13,331

2,602

1,102

2

Soulja Boy Tell Em

130

0

5

2

T-Pain

5,617

237

211

2

Timbaland

2,984

170

86

2

Bow Wow

1,102

15

29

1

Dr. Mehmet Oz

17,901

3,471

927

1

The Game

4,299

903

166

1

Tyler James Williams

17,751

173

257

1

Tyrese Gibson

46,146

4,421

1,045

1

Willie Nelson

15,776

2,453

269

1

 

5. ViralNova.com

 

From

Likes

Shares

Comments

Posts

1,000,000 Pictures

643,991

177,172

32,799

597

Did You Know

506,126

88,199

28,115

237

George Takei

1,047,957

294,725

64,329

55

George Lopez

79,297

21,424

3,343

14

Tommy Chong

59,891

23,582

2,787

13

Cheech and Chong

47,585

27,465

3,573

9

F A C T

743

105

43

7

Ludacris

37,545

4,191

1,111

5

Bow Wow

6,574

389

173

4

Mike "The Situation"

6,939

724

121

4

B.o.B

3,691

267

200

3

Jay Sean

1,817

191

147

3

I Love My Dog

3,203

2,521

245

2

Ne-Yo

8,940

174

97

2

Real men don't cheat on, lie to, or abuse woman.

1,665

905

140

2

Beautiful Amazing World

100

24

4

1

Country Music Nation

174

40

7

1

Cristine Reyes

1,203

240

37

1

Jeff Dunham

12,655

1,663

143

1

Joe Jonas

2,675

138

64

1

JustGirlyThingsღ

2

0

3

1

Keri Hilson

2,006

68

31

1

Maher Zain

56,136

2,773

2,356

1

Robert Downey Jr

144,865

3,915

2,284

1

The Game

3,889

665

250

1

 

6. TheChive.com

 

From

Likes

Shares

Comments

Posts

Cheech and Chong

159,249

49,132

6,120

20

Did You Know

37,301

5,379

1,357

20

Tommy Chong

63,664

30,918

2,374

13

George Lopez

57,875

13,078

2,540

12

George Takei

272,716

121,160

13,634

11

B.o.B

30,142

7,317

3,273

7

Being Mommy

28,877

5,769

465

6

Sean Kingston

11,836

1,549

499

6

Bow Wow

2,750

234

160

4

T-Pain

17,336

4,533

950

4

Lil Jon

2,674

763

124

2

Lil Twist

459

9

20

2

The Game

14,359

2,074

936

2

Jonas Brothers

1,860

62

46

1

Soulja Boy Tell Em

2,101

190

45

1

 

7. Bustle.com

 

From

Likes

Shares

Comments

Posts

George Takei

2,355,646

504,503

148,491

70

Did You Know

91,970

19,699

7,411

57

Being Mommy

83,246

33,622

4,126

50

Moviepilot Vampires

83,162

4,816

841

50

YoMama

2,589

1,068

687

13

Bella Thorne

24,891

166

139

5

Paris Hilton

9,903

385

486

2

Joe Jonas

12,133

850

210

1

Keri Hilson

736

4

9

1

Ludacris

15,000

240

352

1

moviepilot.com

2,401

195

34

1

Oscar Wilde

7,202

1,610

123

1

Sofia Vergara

1,480

61

181

1

Stephen King

25,116

17,934

1,053

1

William Shakespeare

7,431

927

54

1

 

8. MatterDome.com

 

From

Likes

Shares

Comments

Posts

The Game

243,013

21,635

10,225

54

Keri Hilson

104,338

10,387

2,921

47

Being Hyper!

9,885

1,585

736

45

Trey Songz

670,880

36,872

15,981

29

1,000,000 Pictures

6,458

654

166

15

Worldstar Hip Hop

6,811

1,176

822

7

Tyga

46,730

2,859

743

4

Bow Wow

15,636

1,436

230

3

Lil Twist

3,314

111

96

3

Cheech and Chong

8,582

1,993

637

1

Tommy Chong

2,441

1,270

643

1

 

9. APlus.com

 

I covered APlus previously.

 

From

Likes

Shares

Comments

Posts

Ashton Kutcher

21,524,250

5,171,021

830,955

895

Lil Wayne

972,340

91,788

27,939

31

Britney Spears

629,520

51,382

16,423

17

Nicki Minaj

385,999

49,700

13,464

16

T.I.

44,150

6,042

2,015

3

Luciano Huck

26,396

2,174

1,668

2

Being Mommy

7,589

6,524

286

1

Celebs Master

11

1

1

1

Diddy

1,028

75

88

1

Gal Gadot - גל גדות

21,740

501

199

1

عناوين الأخبار

74

7

1

1

 

10. ijReview.com

From

Likes

Shares

Comments

Posts

Liftbump

2,003,229

316,230

95,510

179

Being Mommy

146,851

34,228

13,860

41

Conservative Daily

210,173

64,736

55,959

40

 

11. Distractify.com

 

From

Likes

Shares

Comments

Posts

George Takei

4,977,240

1,289,819

238,445

130

Jonas Brothers

31,783

3,853

1,280

4

Best Vines

184

35

21

1

Cesar Millan

56,190

19,994

1,236

1

Ed Sheeran

29,066

4,633

1,989

1

Real men don't cheat on, lie to, or abuse woman.

132

50

11

1

Si Robertson

2,615

1,181

223

1

 

12. TwentyWords.com

From

Likes

Shares

Comments

Posts

Did You Know

84,663

14,056

2,723

58

George Takei

1,602,044

391,611

55,455

58

YoMama

864

109

13

26

George Lopez

13,089

2,336

587

2

Cheech and Chong

3,919

931

146

1

Jeff Dunham

24,678

3,769

578

1

William Shakespeare

13,967

10,687

375

1

 

13. BroBible.com

From

Likes

Shares

Comments

Posts

Cheech and Chong

72,671

24,188

4,314

10

Mike "The Situation"

7,290

532

148

7

T-Pain

16,526

1,249

439

6

George Takei

38,651

12,574

6,457

5

Tommy Chong

33,573

10,678

2,156

5

Being Mommy

10,315

3,533

701

2

Bow Wow

2,067

47

37

2

Sean Kingston

36,299

2,314

417

2

Waka Flocka Flame

6,843

439

271

2

Arnold Schwarzenegger

40,704

738

400

1

B.o.B

1,703

124

55

1

George Lopez

48,457

9,900

4,573

1

Lil Jon

26,167

1,433

258

1

 

14. Guff.com

From

Likes

Shares

Comments

Posts

George Takei

3,968,051

1,126,498

174,436

181

T-Pain

62,228

5,389

1,381

23

Keri Hilson

30,262

2,187

702

17

Guns N' Roses

105,223

7,072

1,420

6

Backstreet Boys

36,091

1,166

1,404

5

AKON

13,730

613

432

2

Kelly Rowland

60,778

26,177

638

2

Lil Wayne

60,679

1,651

1,489

2

T.I.

12,221

260

269

2

This is just a small sampling of the sites doing this. The sample I used in this case is only 2000 Facebook pages. There are thousands of other influential sites out there. A quick Google search reveals additional sites working with Diply. If you look through any other influencers feeds, such as George Takei, you’ll find a lot of other sites that are partnering with influencers.

Does Facebook want this happening on their site? No. They want accounts posting content related to the name of the account and the paid acquisition going to them. This means that, long-term, this is not a viable strategy as Facebook can change their platform and punish pages that do this. However, short-term, if you want to get a lot of traffic, there is no better way than using Facebook influencers.
Copyright © 2015 Bialerology, All rights reserved.


unsubscribe from this list    update subscription preferences 

Email Marketing Powered by Mailchimp