Let’s talk about Boundaries
In the last issue of Medical Student Update, the article Sex Abuse and You highlighted the importance of the preparation you receive in medical school on issues of professionalism and maintaining appropriate boundaries. We know that many cases of sexual abuse of patients by health professionals are preceded by boundary violations. A pattern of boundary crossings could be the first step towards troubling boundary violations.
The College developed a Boundaries Self- Assessment Tool for physicians to assess their awareness of boundaries and identify the early warning signs. The tool focuses on the area’s most vulnerable to boundary blurring – i.e. gift- giving, physician’s self- disclosure, physician contact and dual relationships. Let’s use the self-assessment tool to reflect on two fictional medical students: Chris and Jan.
Jan
Jan landed a great placement in a vibrant and welcoming community. The placement is going so well that Jan hopes to return to this community to set up a practice. During an ER rotation, Jan felt particularly connected with a patient who happened to share a mutual interest - ultimate Frisbee. The patient asks if Jan is on Facebook - Jan ‘friends’ the patient.
Assessment tool question: Do I seek social contact with certain patients outside of clinically scheduled visits? If so, why?
CPSO recommendation: Seeking social contact with patients outside of clinically scheduled visits is never a recommended activity. Refrain from establishing personal connections with patients or persons closely associated with them online, as this may not allow physicians to maintain appropriate professional boundaries and may compromise physicians’ objectivity. It is acceptable to create an online connection with patients for professional purposes only.
Chris
Since starting medical school, Chris has been bombarded with requests from family and friends to discuss their personal medical issues. On a number of occasions, Chris has been asked for a clinical opinion. As a year two medical student, Chris feels uneasy about providing medical opinions but nevertheless makes recommendations to family members and social acquaintances.
Assessment tool question: Do I find myself making diagnoses for my social acquaintances?
CPSO recommendation: It’s essential that the line between the professional and personal is not blurred – once the line is blurred, there is an increased risk of boundary crossings and violations because objectivity found in the physician-patient relationship is obscured.
The self-assessment tool and boundaries policy are useful to medical students in that it asks clear questions to help you identify, reflect, and be on alert to boundary crossings when they arise. These lessons are just as imperative as your other teachings, as the physician-patient relationship is one that requires trust and mutual respect.
If you have concerns about maintaining boundaries and are looking for confidential advice, you can contact the CPSO Advisory Services line at the 416-967-2600, X603.
Back to top
|