Are crosswalk flags a good value?
Last month we answered the question, “are crosswalk flags effective?”
The answer was yes.
This month we bring cost into the discussion to see how crosswalk flags compare to other traffic control devices.
Here are several common crosswalk traffic control devices and their estimated costs.
(those priced in US$ have been converted to CAD$ at $1.30)
Control device |
Estimated cost |
|
|
HAWK overhead lighting systems |
$100,000+ |
Overhead RA-5 flashing amber beacons |
$20,000 - $50,000 |
Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacons (RRFBs) |
$10,000 - $20,000 |
RA-4 pedestrian signs and 2 lines |
$500 - 1,000 |
In-road crossing pylons |
$500 |
Zebra road markings* |
$250 - $400 |
Crosswalk flags* |
$200 |
*plus annual maintenance costs of approximately 50%
Each device has various degrees of effectiveness and price.
Studies have shown HAWK systems are the most effective, for example, but they come with a steep price tag.
On the other hand, as we showed in our last newsletter crosswalk flags are also quite effective – but at a fraction the cost.
Our conclusion?
Crosswalk flags are effective and inexpensive,
making them an excellent value.
Following are further details for each of these traffic control devices.
|