Copy
Are crosswalk flags a good value? (yes!)
View this email in your browser
Are crosswalk flags a good value?
 
Last month we answered the question, “are crosswalk flags effective?”
 
The answer was yes.
 
This month we bring cost into the discussion to see how crosswalk flags compare to other traffic control devices.
 
Here are several common crosswalk traffic control devices and their estimated costs.
(those priced in US$ have been converted to CAD$ at $1.30)
 
  Control device  Estimated cost
   
  HAWK overhead lighting systems      $100,000+
  Overhead RA-5 flashing amber beacons      $20,000 - $50,000   
      Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacons (RRFBs)           $10,000 - $20,000
  RA-4 pedestrian signs and 2 lines      $500 - 1,000
   In-road crossing pylons      $500
  Zebra road markings*       $250 - $400   
  Crosswalk flags*      $200
*plus annual maintenance costs of approximately 50% 

Each device has various degrees of effectiveness and price. 

Studies have shown HAWK systems are the most effective, for example, but they come with a steep price tag. 
 
On the other hand, as we showed in our last newsletter crosswalk flags are also quite effective – but at a fraction the cost.
 
Our conclusion?
Crosswalk flags are effective and inexpensive,
making them an excellent value.
 
Following are further details for each of these traffic control devices.
High Intensity Activated CrossWalK Beacon (HAWK)
 
HAWK systems are sequenced lighting/beacons starting first with flashing yellow, then steady yellow, and finally steady red over a period of several seconds. Pedestrian signals at either end of the crosswalk display the ‘don't walk’ signal until the HAWK beacon displays the steady red signal.  Only then will the pedestrian light display the white ‘walk’ signal.

A US study on costs prepared for the Federal Highway Administration presents the average cost (in 2012 dollars) of HAWK systems at $75,000.  Other reports have the costs between $75,000 and $150,000
Overhead RA-5 signs with flashing amber beacons
 
Nova Scotia Department of Transportation and Infrastructure Renewal estimates the cost of RA-5 overhead signs with flashing amber beacons including materials, labour, poles, underground wiring and traffic controls at up to $30,000. 

Halifax Regional Municipality estimates costs of between $30,000 and $50,000
 
Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacon (RRFB) 
 
RRFBs have a bright rapid strobe-like warning flash as compared to other flashing crosswalk beacons.  Halifax will be piloting this device at four locations in the near future.
 
One supplier quotes a two-sided system at a cost of approximately $8,500, although there will be additional installation costs.
RA-4 pedestrian signs

RA-4 pedestrian signs are the standard signs posted at a marked crosswalk, attached to a post.

The cost of each of these signs/posts, in conjunction with the painting of two lines across the roadway is $500 to $1,000, depending on number of lanes.

Annual maintenance costs are estimated at $300 to $500, again depending on the number of lanes.

In road crossing signs
 
In road pylons are used in a number of cities and regions including Quebec City, many north-east US states, Georgia, the Carolinas etc.
 
One US supplier quotes the price of a pylon at $500.
‘Zebra’ road markings

 Painting solid zebra road markings is of course more expensive than painting two lines.
 
The cost of ‘zebra’ markings in the Halifax Regional Municipality is $250 to $400 per crosswalk in the first year and $150 to $250 per crosswalk each subsequent year.
 
Nova Scotia Transportation and Infrastructure Renewal use a more expensive slip-resistant thermoplastic material inlayed into the asphalt.  This approach has an initial cost of approximately $2,000 per two-lane crosswalk, although the higher quality material results in significantly lower maintenance costs in subsequent years.
 
Crosswalk flags
 
A crosswalk flag kit (2 crosswalk flag buckets plus 30 crosswalk flags) added to an existing post/infrastructure has an initial cost of $200.
 
The crosswalk flags will not last forever.  As they are depleted (theft or wear and tear) the crosswalk flags will need to be replaced.  The current cost per flag is $5.  It is expected average annual maintenance costs may be $50 to $100.
 
Provided by the
 Crosswalk Safety Society of Nova Scotia

crosswalksafety@eastlink.ca
www.crosswalksafetysociety.ca
Copyright © 2024 Crosswalk Safety Society of Nova Scotia, All rights reserved.


Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list

Email Marketing Powered by Mailchimp