Copy
 

Have trouble viewing this email? View online

 
WINTER 2018
Message from the Chief Municipal Inspector
David-Wolf.jpg

Welcome to this edition of integrity matters where we highlight some of the recent work of the Inspectorate team, and also look at the often problematic issue of confidential information under the Local Government Act and information or communication within councils that is believed to be in confidence.

A significant part of our work over the previous 12 months has involved the campaign donation responsibilities of candidates for local government elections. Transparency of support for candidates is essential for local government, given the potential for campaign donors to be affected by decisions of council and for improper conflicts of interest to exist.

For that reason, my office undertakes extensive work in providing information and guidance to candidates and examines candidate compliance in general elections and by-elections to ensure laws have been met. While the response by candidates from the Geelong and Melbourne by-elections was encouraging, 15 candidates from the last general election flouted the law and prosecutions resulted.

Recently I have spoken with different groups from the sector about conflicts of interest and the legislative framework that applies to councillors, special committee members and council staff under the Local Government Act. The laws envisage that councillors, committee members and staff have interests in their own community, and provide a framework which allows them, in many circumstances, to participate in discussions and decision making. Local government is unique in having a legislated framework for conflicts and my office will be focusing our guidance and education efforts on this over the next year.

David Wolf

Chief Municipal Inspector

hr-line.jpg
Is it confidential, does it matter?
confidential envelope

The Inspectorate receives many complaints where it is alleged confidential information has been released from council which harmed the business or reputation of council.

Unauthorised release of information has a range of adverse outcomes for councils. At the more serious level, it may relate to private, commercial, legal or personal information. Other circumstances include where issues are discussed in council and those discussions are publicly disclosed without approval from those involved.

The Inspectorate supports open and transparent local government but also recognises the legislative need to protect information. Confidentiality is also important in many cases to allow for effective council operations.

The Inspectorate investigates allegations where information has been deemed confidential by the process set out in the Local Government Act (section 77). The council CEO is responsible for the process to designate information as confidential and penalties may apply for any person subject tosection 77(1) who releases that information.

 

A common complaint received by the Inspectorate relates to material or information that is understood to be in confidence but is disclosed without authorisation or agreement. Where information has not been designated confidential under the Act, it is the council's role to manage confidentiality and this is achieved through councillor and staff codes of conduct.

In some circumstances, the Inspectorate may investigate the improper use of information by a councillor regardless of whether it has been deemed confidential. This may constitute one of the more serious offences in the Act, misuse of position. The Inspectorate is currently prosecuting multiple charges related to a misuse of position against former Murrindindi councillor Chris Healy with the determination to be made on 10 October.

hr-line.jpg
Importance of interest return disclosures
ordinary return form

Councillors have recently been required to submit their half-yearly ordinary interest returns, an important document for recording their interests in their municipality and flagging other positions and obligations. Non-disclosure can attract significant penalties for non-compliance.

Recently, Wyndham councillor Intaj Khan was convicted and fined $26,000 in Sunshine Magistrates Court after pleading guilty to eight charges for repeated failures related to the filing of interest returns.

The Inspectorate commenced criminal proceedings against Cr Khan in 2017 with three charges of failing to disclose companies in which he held office during the return period; three charges of failing to disclose companies in which he held a financial interest; and two charges of failing to submit ordinary returns between February 2016 and February 2017.

Cr Khan has lodged an appeal against the sentence which is listed for 14 September in the County Court.

These charges are not disqualifying offences under the Local Government Act 1989 and Cr Khan remains entitled to serve as a councillor. More information on the outcome is in our media release: www.go.vic.gov.au/qeMamV

The penalty comes after Cr Khan received a warning from the Inspectorate in 2015 for a similar offence and was provided additional training by his council.

Chief Municipal Inspector David Wolf said: "The laws relating to interest returns support the transparency and integrity of local government. For councillors, they are an important guide to help avoid conflicts of interest".

hr-line.jpg
When it's not a conflict

The Inspectorate recently received a complaint regarding a councillor participating in a matter before council relating to an entity in which they held a position.

The complaint alleged a conflict of interest but on review, the councillor had been appointed to the position by council as a nominee director, which is exempt under section 78B(3)(ba) of the Local Government Act 1989.

The current conflict of interest provisions in the Act often enable councillors to participate in matters, accepting that they have broad interests in the community and are able to participate in decisions where the aforementioned exemptions apply.

hr-line.jpg
Campaign donation transparency

It was pleasing to note that after a program of reminders and compliance checks on campaign donation returns during recent by-elections, all candidates have submitted their returns. One Melbourne Council candidate received a warning for late submission.

The Inspectorate has now mostly finalised prosecutions for candidates who failed to submit campaign donation returns in the 2016 general elections.

As a result of prosecutions so far, candidates have been ordered to pay fines totalling more than $8,000 and more than $14,000 in legal costs.

As reported in the Inspectorate's autumn newsletter, a comprehensive compliance program started after the 2016 general elections to ensure all candidates had submitted campaign donation returns according to section 62 of the Act.

 

All candidates who have been charged have also been ordered to comply with their obligations to submit their returns.

Chief Municipal Inspector David Wolf said, "A key factor in the integrity of local government is ensuring the transparency of who has financially supported candidates and councillors. While we don't take prosecution action lightly, it is important that we pursue these matters and allow the courts to determine the seriousness of the offence."

hr-line.jpg

Name change

You may have noticed that the Local Government Investigations and Compliance Inspectorate has shortened and simplified its name to the Local Government Inspectorate.

The order approving the change was made on 3 May 2018 by the Governor in Council in accordance with the Public Administration Act 2004.

The website address has changed to www.lgi.vic.gov.au and previous links that include /lgici will redirect to the new web domain. Website content and other communications will be changed to reflect the new title.

 

Out and about

Chief Municipal Inspector David Wolf and Investigations Team Leader David Walker took part in the Minimising Corruption, Fraud and Misconduct conference in Sydney in May, delivering a case study on the Inspectorate's work and joining a panel discussion with NSW and interstate government agencies.

The Inspectorate also provided insight to mayors and governance staff with the Chief Municipal Inspector attending the MAV Mayors Roundtable and LGPro Governance Group forum.

hr-line.jpg
What's on
Events and reminders
Friday 3 August 2018

VLGA Mayoral group

Monday 30 June & Monday 31 December 2018

Ordinary returns to be lodged with CEO on this date or within 40 days

hr-line.jpg
Questions or comments on this newsletter or our website?

Please complete our survey at http://svy.mk/2ckfkCo or email media.comms@lgici.vic.gov.au (please note: this form is only for feedback on the newsletter or website - we cannot accept complaints about local councils on this survey form).

Should you wish to submit a complaint, click here.

For more about our work, visit www.lgi.vic.gov.au or follow our Twitter account @CMI_Vic.

 






This email was sent to <<Email Address>>
why did I get this?    unsubscribe from this list    update subscription preferences
Local Government Inspectorate · PO Box 4912 · Melbourne, Vic 3001 · Australia