Copy
OCTOBER 27, 2018
View this email in your browser
Share
Tweet
Forward
By Bryce Couch

ELECTION DETECTION

Brazilians will go to the polls tomorrow, October 28, to cast their ballots in the second round of the presidential election. The election will see frontrunner and far-right candidate Jair Bolsonaro of the Social Liberal Party (PSL), face off against leftist Fernando Haddad of the Workers’ Party (PT). Bolsonaro earlier failed to secure the absolute majority necessary to secure the presidency outright, only receiving 46 percent in the first round on October 7. Second-place finisher Haddad received just over 29 percent. The two candidates represent vastly different visions for Brazil in an election that will have profound effects on the region. Read on for in-depth analysis from Compass World.

Fernando Hadded
Jair Bolsonaro

THE BOLSONARO EFFECT

A Bolsonaro-Haddad runoff was widely predicted as the inevitable outcome of the first-round vote, according to analysts. However, Bolsonaro performed better than was expected. In the Chamber of Deputies, Bolsonaro’s PSL made significant gains, securing 52 seats compared to PT’s 56. In 2014, PSL had only one candidate elected as a federal deputy. PSL secured four senatorial seats compared to PT’s six. The results of these elections represented a defeat for traditional centrist parties in addition to the leftist PT. Although voting is mandatory in Brazil, abstention rates reached 20.32 percent, the highest rate since the 1998 election.

POLICY POLICE

The candidates have not appeared in a televised debate together. Bolsonaro has cited medical recovery from injuries sustained when he was stabbed at an election rally in September. Instead, the candidates have engaged on Twitter. Bolsonaro has criticized Haddad as a puppet of imprisoned former-President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, while Haddad has ridiculed Bolsonaro’s refusal to engage in televised debates.

Venezuela Crisis

Bolsonaro has painted the election as a choice between voting for freedom and democracy (voting for him) or voting for “the path of Venezuela” (voting for Haddad). Bolsonaro is an active critic of Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro. Additionally, Bolsonaro paints immigration as a national security issue. He is opposed to Venezuelan immigration to Brazil and proposed the creation of refugee camps in the states of Roraima and Amazonas.

On the other hand, Haddad has been incapable of shedding the historical relationship between the Workers’ Party and the administration of former-President of Venezuela Hugo Chávez under Lula. Haddad favors diplomatic dialogue rather than military intervention to end the crisis. The PT’s official position recognizes the legitimate rule of the Maduro regime and condemns international criticism of the May elections. On immigration, Haddad believes it is important to resettle migrants throughout the country in order to avoid their concentration in poor regions.
 

Trade: China, Mercosur, and Regional Integration
 
On China, Bolsonaro recognizes the importance to the Brazilian economy of the Asian giant, yet he has expressed concern over China’s growing stake in the Brazilian energy sector, saying, “China isn’t buying in Brazil. China is buying Brazil.” On the other hand, Haddad supports the BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa) trade bloc and Mercosur (Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay, Uruguay, and—until recently—Venezuela), arguing that to expand the economic recovery, it is vital to increase bilateral and multilateral trade agreements. Bolsonaro called for a review of participation in these organizations and has vowed to rewrite the Mercosur agreement.
 
Security Reform

Bolsonaro advocates a fight-violence-with-violence strategy. To combat increasing crime rates, Bolsonaro has suggested allowing the people to use weapons without fees or formal registration. He also defends ending investigations against police officers accused of excessive use of force. Bolsonaro also favors a withdrawal from all treaties on human rights.

The PT party proposed a public safety strategy in August that aims to reduce the number of homicides.The plan strengthens information systems and arm control policies, specifically removing the distribution and circulation of illegal weapons while curbing arms trafficking.

ELECTORAL VIOLENCE

Reports of violence have increased during this electoral period. One of the most publicized cases is the murder of a capoeira teacher in early October by a Bolsonaro supporter after he defended his support for Haddad. Several other reports have been made in recent weeks from minority groups claiming to have been threatened over differences in political opinion. Both Bolsonaro and Haddad have condemned acts of political violence.

Amnesty International condemned the rise of electoral violence on October 18. The statement released by Amnesty International raised concerns that many attacks may have been hate crimes, motivated on the grounds of race, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity, or political opinions. Jurema Werneck, the executive director of Amnesty International Brazil, wrote, “All Brazilians have the right to participate in the electoral process without being subject to any kind of coercion, discrimination, or retaliation by anyone.” The organization urged the Brazilian authorities to investigate the reports and ensure that this does not happen again.

CONTROVERSY

The first round results were indicative of a growing sense of disillusionment with the political establishment. Growing disenchantment spurred by Brazil’s economic recession coupled with high crime rates and corruption scandals amongst the political elite have spurred the rise of populist candidates and a desire for new solutions. To many, Bolsonaro, a long-term congressman representing Rio de Janeiro, is that change. If Bolsonaro symbolizes change, Haddad, former-mayor of São Paulo, symbolizes continuity.

Low degrees of trust in government institutions combined with polarized opinions about the leading candidates have fueled divisions within Brazil.

As the representative of the Workers’ Party, Haddad carries with him a dual legacy of its successes and more recent scandals. Lula was barred from running for election and jailed for violating Brazil’s Clean State Law. In 2014, authorities launched operation Car Wash, a corruption investigation that resulted in the conviction of Lula and the impeachment of former-President Dilma Rousseff. On October 17, the federal police requested that the Prosecutor’s Office indict incumbent President Michel Temer on charges of corruption, money laundering, and criminal activity, as well as ten other individuals.

Critics of Jair Bolsonaro have been vocal, condemning the candidate for his previous behavior that has resulted in federal hate speech charges for homophobic, misogynistic, and racist comments. However, opponents have expressed fear over the potential rise of the military under a Bolsonaro administration due to apologist comments defending the Brazilian military dictatorship between 1964 and 1985.

Polarized opinions fueled demonstrations in the days leading up to the vote. Although anti-Bolsonaro protests were widespread on October 21, pro-Bolsonaro rallies on October 22 were larger in scale and more widespread throughout the country. Appearing via teleconference, Bolsonaro delivered a speech about re-building Brazil and purging the country of left-wing “outlaws.”

WHAT'S IN STORE?

To overcome the 18-point gap going into the election, Haddad is trying to appeal to all sides, specifically by speaking to the importance of unity and moving forward together. To counteract Bolsonaro’s support from the Evangelical community, Haddad has made efforts to gain support from the Catholic Church.

In recent weeks, Bolsonaro softened his tone ahead of the second-round vote to maximize his appeal. In doing so, Bolsonaro has sought to increase his appeal with women, people of color, and the LGBTQ community. For example, Bolsonaro was recently endorsed by Agustin Fernandez, a famous, gay makeup artist.

In recent weeks, Haddad saw his rejection rate from to 41 percent from 47 percent while Bolsonaro’s rose from 35 percent to 40 percent. The most recent study conducted by IBOPE Intelligence projected 57 percent for Bolsonaro and 43 percent for Haddad, compared to a 59-41 percent split in the previous poll. The recent polling matches the data from other polls that show Bolsonaro securing between 57 percent (CNT/MDA) and 60 percent (BTG/FSB) of the vote.

Stay tuned for continued, live coverage by Compass World on our social media platforms.
Copyright © 2018, The Caravel, All rights reserved.
Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list






This email was sent to <<Email Address>>
why did I get this?    unsubscribe from this list    update subscription preferences
The Caravel · Georgetown University · 3700 O St. NW · Washington, DC 20057 · USA

Email Marketing Powered by Mailchimp