|
Dear colleagues and friends,
This is meant as a quick update regarding our activities during the months of May and June 2022.
[Mailing list explanation: I started using an email mailing list to keep those who work with me, know me, and/or attend my activities updated about all that we're doing in my lab at HKU. I am hoping to help you in your research activities and slowly build a community interested in open-science to promote a science reform. I add those who have asked me or corresponded with me about my research or activities. If you're not interested in further updates, links to unsubscribe available at the bottom. If others want to join or view previous emails: https://mgto.org/giladmailinglist ]
Open-science talks
I gave the following talks :
- 2022-05-18 @PUC: Cognitive biases in researchers and the research process: Summarizing ~100 replications on heuristics and biases and discussing implications, challenges, and potential remedies for improving science
- OSF with slides, video, and poster
- YouTube video
- 2022-05-20 @UDP: Challenges with meta-analyses - Towards reproducibility & transparency with reproducible meta-analysis Registered Reports
- OSF with slides
- (technology glitch, video was lost)
- 2022-05-30 @UdeSA: Towards community collaborative open science:
Peer Community in Registered Reports as the future of science
- OSF with slides, video, and poster
- YouTube video
- 2022-06-03 @UBA: Endorsing open-science & promoting a science reform Status, issues, challenges, & initial solutions
- OSF with slides, video, and poster
- YouTube video
- 2022-06-07 @China Open Science Network: Peer Community in Registered Report as the future of science: Our experience from 15 in-process scheduled PCIRR replication and extension submissions
- OSF with slides, video, and poster
- YouTube video
All talks are recorded and shared on OSF and YouTube.
Scheduled PCI-RR Stage 1 in-principle acceptances
In the previous mailing list update I wrote about my attempt to run all thesis projects this year as Peer Community in Registered Reports submissions. We have so far submitted 9 guided thesis student projects and additional 6 team projects based on course-work in my classes.
As of today, all 15 projects received an invitation to revise and resubmit with positive feedback. Of those, 8 projects have already received the Stage 1 in-principle acceptance from PCIRR (!).
Collabra:Psychology journal has expressed interest in publishing all of our team's IPA submissions, and after review by their editorial board has so far agreed to honor the PCIRR Stage 2 submission for all the project that they reviewed.
This means, that the work done by the thesis students, and the course students led by invited early-career researchers, have all met the highest standards in our field with approval by both Peer Community in Registered Reports and Collabra:Psychology.
I expect that the other 7 will receive similar approvals in the upcoming two months.
I will keep updating about our progress with this. I do hope to see all those officially accepted by end of 2023.
The nice thing about PCIRR is that you can actually see all the review process, all our submissions in every step, and how we responded to the peer review.
Here are all 8 projects that already received a Stage 1 in-principle acceptance:
(underlined: supervised students; ^: corresponding author; italic: invited ECR)
- Yeung, K., & ^Feldman, G. (2023 expected). Revisiting stigma attributions and reactions to stigma: Replication and extensions of Weiner et al. (1988). [IPA] [Preprint] [OSF]
- Zhu, M. & ^Feldman. G. (2023 expected). Revisiting the links between numeracy and decision making: Replication of Peters et al. (2006) with an extension examining confidence. [IPA] [Preprint] [OSF]
- Li, M. & ^Feldman, G. (2023 expected). Revisiting mental accounting classic paradigms: Replication of the experiments reviewed in Thaler (1999). [IPA] [Preprint] [OSF]
- Yiu, S., & ^Feldman, G. (2023 expected). Revisiting the psychological sources of ambiguity avoidance: Replication and extensions of Curley, Yates, and Abrams (1986). [IPA] [Preprint] [OSF]
- Lee, S., & ^Feldman, G. (2023 expected). Revisiting the link between true-self and morality: Replication and extensions of Newman, Bloom and Knobe (2014) Studies 1 and 2. [IPA] [Preprint] [OSF]
- Lu, S. & ^Feldman, G. (2023 expected). Associations of fear, anger, happiness, and hope with risk judgments: Revisiting appraisal-tendency framework with a replication and extensions of Lerner and Keltner (2001). [IPA] [Preprint] [OSF]
- Li, M., & ^Feldman, G. (2023 expected) Revisiting diversification bias and partition dependence: Replication and extensions of Fox, Ratner, and Lieb (2005) Studies 1, 2, and 5. [IPA] [Preprint] [OSF]
- Zhang, Y., Cheung, F., Wong, H., Yuen, L., Sin, H., Chow, H., & ^Feldman, G.. (2023 expected). Revisiting the role of public exposure and moral beliefs on feelings of shame and guilt: Replication of Smith et al. (2002)’s Study 1. [IPA] [Preprint] [OSF]
In-press publications
(*: equal contribution; underlined: supervised students; ^: corresponding author; italic: invited ECR)
New publications:
- *Chandrashekar, S. P., *Chan, Y., *Cheng, K., Yao, J., Lo, C., Cheung, T., Tang, H., Leung, Y., Tsoi, C., Cheng, B., Ng, K., & ^Feldman, G. (2022). Revisiting the Folk Concept of Intentionality: Replications of Malle and Knobe (1997). Journal of Experimental Social Psychology. DOI: j.jesp.2022.104372 [Article] [Preprint] [OSF]
For a full list of publications and preprints from the mass replication project see: https://mgto.org/pre-registered-replications/#preprints
Twitter prediction markets
Given all the registered reports that we're running, I ran a quick predictions survey on Twitter to see what the Twitter community thought is going to replicate. Very interesting findings in there. You're welcome to have a look at the following link (click on it):
Twitter replication prediction markets.
|
