Copy
View this email in your browser

In which we travel to an unknown Italian town, consider evil great grandmothers, and pick out three books we can't wait to read.

Whereabouts by Jhumpa Lahiri

I picked this up the last time I was at the bookshop – I’m still so excited by the idea of being able to select from real physical books in an actual shop I have been tending to get a bit carried away with my purchases recently. Anyone else had that problem?

But happily, this proved to be an excellent choice. I was in the middle of half-term week which was a busy family time and though I’d bought this on impulse I hadn’t expected to be reading it. 

But from the very first page I was captivated – so much so that I found myself stealing away whenever I could to read a few more pages. Partly it was the writing style, which is so beautifully poised reading it it felt like a kind of meditation. Lahiri wrote it in Italian (not her first language) and then translated it into English – perhaps this accounts for the way every word seems so beautifully weighted. I was also drawn in because of its themes: ‘Solitude’ she writes, ‘it’s become my trade. As it requires a certain discipline, it’s a condition I try to perfect’ which fitted nicely with my yearning to have some time for myself.

It seems to sit in that genre of fiction writing – auto-fiction – that is drawn from the writer’s own life. It is narrated by an unmarried woman living alone in an unnamed Italian city. We learn of her daily routine, her office at the university where she works, her interactions with friends and acquaintances, where she eats lunch. It’s full of small observations that in less expert hands might seem boring but here are somehow compelling. Details of her difficult relationship with her parents, her mother still living, her father long gone, adds a darker undercurrent that stops it feeling frivolous or throwaway. 

Reading a few reviews I was surprised to see one critic categorise it as a book about depression, something I’d definitely sensed within the book, but I wouldn’t have said was a major theme. Thinking back over it I remembered the scene where the author explains that she struggles in spring, finding there are days when she doesn’t want to get out of bed, and other scenes where she visits a therapist. It seemed to me that her depression was woven in as just one more facet of a person’s life, something as much a part of her as her teaching and where she chose to eat lunch – and I liked this way of writing about it.

It’s a hard book to sum up. I finished it and wasn’t quite sure what I had just read, only that I’d loved the experience of reading it. I recommend it for anyone in the mood for a book that will take you on a journey. You get to inhabit a city in Italy and experience it through the eyes of another person in such a way that you will feel as if you have been there with her yourself.

Buy Whereabouts from Bookshop.org

Further reading: Olivia Laing feels like a good fit for this. Her book The Lonely City is subtitled 'adventures in the art of being alone'. Deborah Levy calls it 'a stunning homage to how extreme loneliness can make us more hospitable to the strangeness of others – to the risks and innovations of art and artists. Laing has written a classic that will be cherished for years to come'. Levy's own living autobiography series, Things I Don't Want To KnowThe Cost of Living and most recently Real Estate also come to mind as Levy considers the life of a divorced woman in her 40s, 50s and turning 60. Laced through with feminism and literary reference points they are unmissable. And there's something of Lahiri's powerful quietness in Hotel du Lac by Anita Brookner, her famous novel about a woman exiled to a Swiss hotel by a lake after a romantic indescretion. Wandering the streets of the boring little town and interacting with the other hotel guests – all taking refuge from real life in some way or another – she considers whether or not to take charge of her own fate. Also, the only other thing I had read by Jhumpa Lahiri was a lovely essay called The Clothing of Books in which she explores the art of the book jacket, which I also recommend.
Great Granny Webster by Caroline Blackwood

A discovery thanks to Molly Young (whose Read Like The Wind newsletter I recommended last week) this appeared in my postbox from the library. It begins ‘I was sent to stay with her two years after the war had ended, but in her house it seemed to be war-time. Her blinds and curtains were often drawn even during the day as if she was still preserving some kind of conscientious “black-out”. I think she was more frightened of the sun than she had ever been of German raids. She owned gloomy and valuable Persian carpets and it seemed to be her terror that some stray and sneaking sunbeam would creep in and make them fade.’ 

In it a young English girl is sent to stay with her great-grandmother after a minor operation where it’s thought the sea air will agree with her. She arrives at her grandmother’s gloomy mansion in Hove pleasantly anticipating a treat, but soon discovers her great-grandmother is one of the world’s most miserable people who prefers to spend almost all her time sitting silently upright in an enormously uncomfortable chair. ‘She often seemed to be trying to use her hard chair as camouflage, as if she hoped that Death might enter her drawing-room and leave again, tricked by her tactics – that he would think he had already taken her, she showed so much less sign of life than her wooden chair.’ The closest the child gets to the sea is measured drives along the sea-front in her grandmother’s Rolls Royce with the windows cracked open an inch. 

It’s hard to say what I loved most about this novella, which having introduced the monstrous great-granny then goes on to explore some of the other people in the author’s family, from her her grandmother and grandfather to her merrily depressed aunt. Granny Blackwood is wealthy but also miserly and won’t spend a penny to help her daughter, married to an Anglo-Irish member of the landed-gentry who is unable to maintain his crumbling ancestral home. Meanwhile the girl’s father was killed in the war, and although she doesn’t remember him much this tragic event is not without psychological repercussions. 

It is the most effective blend of humour and despair I think I might ever have read. Blackwood narrowly missed out on winning the 1977 Booker Prize. Chair of judges Philip Larkin cast the deciding vote against it, declaring it a memoir, not a novel. Funnily enough we had just been having the same debate on the podcast over Patricia Lockwood’s No One Is Talking About This. Having read this work of genius I now think Larkin an idiot to have passed it over, and feel slightly embarrassed by my own arguments that while I love fictionalised memoirs on their own merits I think it not quite fair to measure them up against novels whose authors have invented all the details. Writing this good should be rewarded.

Buy Great Granny Webster from Bookshop.org

Further reading: 

Tonally the complete opposite but I did of course think of Aunt Ada Doom, the monstrous elderly relation in Cold Comfort Farm by Stella Gibbons, who once saw something nasty in the woodshed and keeps the whole Starkadder family in a state of nervous terror lest she have one of her ‘episodes’ again. It’s a novel as full of joy as Great Granny Webster is full of despair, if you’ve never read it a treat is in store. Also I enjoyed this Irish Times article on Blackwood who calls her 'an expert analyst of female fury'.

Three to Try

 

Monday or Tuesday by Virginia Woolf

Every year on a Thursday in mid-June (echoing the date of Clarissa Dalloway’s party) the RSL celebrate Dalloway Day. This year’s is on June 17th and they are focusing on Virginia Woolf’s only collection of short stories, Monday or Tuesday. Join them for walking tours, a writing workshop and a series of talks including Deborah Levy and Serve Emre on Virginia Woolf and Kate Mosse, Claire Wilcox and Shahidha Bari on fashion and objects.

Empire of Pain by Patrick Radden-Keefe

Patrick Radden-Keefe’s exploration of the Sackler family and America’s opioid crisis. Every review I’ve read of this one has been a rave and I loved his previous book, Say Nothing, about Northern Ireland. I think this is going to be riveting and I can’t wait to get to it.




The Woman in the Purple Skirt by Natsuko Imamura

I heard about this one via one of my favourite Instagram accounts, Yuki over at @booknerdtokyo. In the way of Instagram I have a vague sense that she’s partly American, partly Japanese, and her captions are bilingual. She writes beautifully about books, is always considering the nuances of language and translation and has an eye for interesting reads. Anyway, of this she writes: ‘We meet the Woman in the Purple Skirt, who is called the Woman in the Purple Skirt throughout. We’re told of her weird quirks, habits, lifestyle choices. We think, “wow she's weird.” But then, we read a few pages. And we keep reading because the story is engaging. And we don't realise until it's too late that the tables have turned and the Woman in the Purple Skirt isn’t actually not the weird one. Not by a long shot.’ The cover has a quote from Leïla Slimani promising ‘you will be obsessed’. It sounds promising for book club.

 

What to Listen To


Don't miss our latest episode celebrating all things Happy Reader magazine. If you haven't yet come across it, every few months or so Penguin produce this absolute gem, which you can buy individually or subscribe for a year. You get an in-depth interview with a cultural figure focusing on their reading life, and then a series of articles all linked more or less tangentially to the book of the season. The latest one is just out featuring 'sonic trailblazer Moses Sumney', while the book is Madonna in a Fur Coat by Turkish author Sabahattin Ali (heard of it? Not me – like all the best book clubs this magazine helps expand my reading horizons). My favourite one of all time, just in case you were wondering, is issue 7, which features Hans Ulrich Obrist, an art curator who visits a bookshop every day of his life and in between doing a million productive things in the art world still finds time to read and rearrange the toppling piles of books in his apartment. 

But I digress – do listen in to hear editor Seb Emina on all the thought and care that goes into creating the magazine, from planning a real-life treasure hunt to the perfect way to drink your tea. He gives us his favourite book discoveries and some interesting new ideas for book club meet ups. It's episode #98, available now.

Also, not to go on about it, but I'm still riveted to the Graham Norton Book Club on Audible. The latest episode is just out, focusing on Lanny, which we also did – and were distinctly more critical of – on our pod. I loved this discussion though, and agree wholeheartedly with all the praise.

 

What Kate is reading:

I'm enjoying Excellent Women by Barbara Pym, which turned up at the library at the same time as Granny Webster. I hadn't read any Barbara Pym before and feel very late to the party, but now I'm there I'm loving it. Also To The Lake by Kapka Kassabova, which I'm picking up and putting down at odd moments. It's a beautifully written exploration of place and her family history, but there's a lot there, so I like to read a bit and then have a break before coming back to it.
 

What Laura is reading

Excitingly Laura has a weekend off, and reports back that she's been discovering the TV series Quantum Leap (and check out our recent Bookshelf episode for why she might be curious) over room service in bed.

Thanks so much for subscribing to our newsletter, we hope you're enjoying them. Do get in touch at thebookclubreview@gmail.com or via our website. Let us know what you're reading – we always love to hear from you.

Anytime you're in the mood for a books podcast do check out our archive of almost 100 (we're nearly there) episodes from book club discussions to our bookshelf round-ups and interviews with book clubs far and wide and people from inside the book world.

And if you enjoyed the newsletter do forward it on to a book-loving friend. Sign up link is here. Spreading the word is the best possible way to support us and we are so grateful when people do. But for now, until next week, happy reading.

Share Share
Tweet Tweet
Forward Forward
Instagram
Facebook
Twitter
Website
Copyright © 2021 The Book Club Review, All rights reserved.


Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list.

Email Marketing Powered by Mailchimp