Writing News
Structural edit notes came back from my editor and agent not long after the last newsletter went out. They were both pleased with What Will Burn, but as ever had some good ideas as to how it could be better. I've spent most of the past month taking out about 15,000 words and putting in another 9000 or so. I'd hoped to trim the thing down a bit more, but sometimes that's not how it works.
I like the editing process, mostly. I've read of some authors who approach the whole thing in an adversarial manner - fighting their corner for their art sort of thing. I've never been able to understand that attitude. Your editor is on your side. They are trying to make your book better, and they're bringing a fresh and trained set of eyes to your work. That's not to say that everything your editor suggests is right, or that you need to implement all the changes they suggest. At the end of the day it's my name on the cover, not my editor's. But even when they suggest things you don't agree with, that can be a useful sign that what you're trying to do hasn't worked. If your editor misunderstands your intent, then it's probably not because they are stupid, and it's likely all your other readers will misunderstand too.
As an example (and mild spoilers), a strand of What Will Burn involves what I intended to be a case of workplace sexual harassment, with the woman being the one abusing her power over a subordinate man. My editor thought this came across as harmless flirting, and seemed both out of character and unnecessary. He'd missed the point I was trying to make, and his suggestion was that I take it out. Had it been simply flirting, taking it out would have been fine, but that wasn't what it was supposed to be. That he hadn't got it meant that other readers would likely do the same, and the power dynamic between the two characters is actually important to the development of the plot. So rather than taking out the flirting, I had to find a way to make it more obvious that what was going on was far from harmless.
Some stuff can be taken out, of course. In The Gathering Dark, each day starts with McLean waking up in a cold sweat, having had nightmares sparked by the horror of the truck crash he witnessed at the start of the book. In the first draft, I included the actual nightmares and dropped in hints to the strange, otherworldly forces at play. They added nothing, and reading them a month or so after having written them they were actually a bit embarrassing. All we need to know is that poor old Tony is suffering from PTSD after the crash, and having him regularly waking up in a cold sweat, sometimes with the ghost of a scream still on his lips, is enough. The rest can be left to the reader's imagination.
You'd think I'd learn, but apparently not. I also wrote a series of scenes from victim's point of view in What Will Burn. Each shows an unknown man dying in a strange and unsettling way - something of a theme in the book. The problem is that the scenes give away what's happening long before McLean puzzles it out. I'm not particularly writing whodunnits, but a story can become dull quite quickly if the main protagonist is too many steps behind the reader.
The edit for that problem was simple - remove the scenes. The details become apparent as McLean and the team investigate the unusual deaths, with each one adding a little more to the bigger picture.
There is something very liberating about deleting large chunks of text, even as I remember the blood, sweat and tears that went into writing them in the first place. And nothing is ever really wasted. When the book comes out next year I'll almost certainly post some of those deleted scenes in the newsletter. Lucky you!
US and Canadian eBooks!
My little experiment in self-publishing across the pond continues apace. Slightly fewer sales in August, but I haven't had any new titles to publish and have been too busy with edits to do any promotion. The object of the exercise was never to get rich so much as to make the books available so that readers don't need to go looking on the pirate download sites and end up with malware-infested fake copies. On that basis any sales at all are a bonus. I'm quite pleased with the covers I knocked up for the two Con Fairchild books though.
|