Copy

Energy Transition Group (ETG)

The Energy Transition Group has been formed by individuals from the University of Northern BC (UNBC) and the Prince George Electric Vehicle Association (PG EVA) to encourage informative discussions with guest experts about all aspects of the ongoing energy transition.


  • Welcome To The May Energy Transition Group Newsletter


  • Reoccurring Monthly Events


  • Upcoming EV Events


  • All-Candidate Forums


  • Seeking Your Input


  • New BC Hydro Solar And Battery Rebates


  • New BC Hydro Rate Design Application


  • How China Got To Dominate The Energy Transition


  • Unpacking Fossil Fuel Subsidies In Canada


  • Another Subsidy Of Up To $200 Million To Coastal Gaslink


  • The Energy Transition Is Well Underway


  • Updated Provincial Scorecard


  • Petition For Near Zero Methane Emissions By 2030


  • The Truth About Fossil Fuels


  • World-first: EVs Power Grid During Outage In Australia


  • DC Solar To DC Charging Your EV


  • Diesel Versus Battery Electric Transport Trucks


  • Hydrogen Versus Battery Electric Transport Trucks


  • Cost Of Transitioning From ICE To EV Medium And Heavy Trucks


  • Public Persuasion Episode Of The Energy Transition Show


  • Rising Insurance Costs


  • Electric Plane For Flight Training


  • Improvements With Extracting Lithium From Liquids


  • Will Thermal Trapping Of Solar Heat Allow The Smelting OfSteel And Cooking Of Cement?


  • Are EVs Really Better For The Climate?


  • Are EVs Worse For The Environment?


  • Which Pollutes More – EV Or Gas Vehicle?


  • Sankey Flowchart Explained


  • Draft Quebec Bill Would Ban PHEVs


  • Gas Stations Are In Decline


  • Compensation Sought For Scuttled Keystone XL Pipeline Declined




Welcome To The May Energy Transition Group Newsletter


The Energy Transition Group is open to discussing any energy transition related topics as guided by your input.


Please provide information for sharing in future Energy Transition Group Newsletters and for discussion at our monthly Energy Transition Group meetings



Reoccurring Monthly Events


  • Energy Transition Group (ETG) monthly meeting

    Tuesday August 13th 6:30 pm to 8:00 pm - the 2nd Tuesday of each month

    UNBC Prince George Building 5 Room 173 or attend virtually via Zoom

    https://unbc.zoom.us/j/67250820843?pwd=0qmyaZvJ7wmE4Jm1iW4IK1lC6Saijq.1Meeting ID: 672 5082 0843     Pass code: 435276


    IS THE ENERGY TRANSITION DO-ABLE?


    Presenter:  Doug Beckett

    Doug has been driving electric vehicles in Prince George since 2009, is the founder and facilitator of the Prince George Electric Vehicle Association, Co-founder of the UNBC Energy Transition Group, and has been appointed to the BC Government Zero Emissions Vehicle Council.


    Doug’s presentation, Is The Energy Transition Do-able?, provides a reflection as to where BC currently is at with its energy use, and what BC’s energy use may look like as the transition occurs.  Most importantly, what will this energy transition mean to your wallet?


    Ann Doung’s topic – see 2 articles below.


    Update on the All-Candidate Forums.


    Topic and Guest Expert input


  • EV Meet-Up ~8:00 pm (following the 6:30 to 8:00pm ETG meeting) in the UNBC parking lot, near the EV Chargers





Upcoming EV Events


  • EVs in the Hixon Fall Fair Parade

    Saturday, August 10, 2024 9:00 am to 12:00 noon


  • Touch a Truck Event

    The Prince George Public Library ever-popular Touch a Truck event!

    Friday August 23, 2024 9:00 am to 3:00 pm

    Canada Games Plaza (in front of the Civic Centre and Bob Harkins Branch of the Prince George Public Library)


  • Labour Day Event

    Canada Games Plaza

    Monday September 2nd, 2024 from 9:30 am to 3:00 pm

    I am hoping to have an EV powering a bouncy castle for the children.  The electric train from the Rail and Forestry Museum will be giving free rides.


    There will be a lot of free stuff for children and adults, including BBQ, face painting, snow cones, Belly Buttons the Clown, Bouncy Castle, Rail and Forestry Museum Mini Train rides and more . . . . .



  • Valemount EV Event

    Friday,September 27 at the Valemount high school


All-Candidate Forums


The University of Northern BC Energy Transition Group, the Prince George Electric Vehicle Association, and the University of Northern BC Sustainability Team are hosting 3 all-candidate forums.  One forum for each of the 3ridings which intersect Prince George.






All candidates running in each of the Prince George – Valemount,  Prince George– Cariboo North and Prince George – Mackenzie ridings for the up coming provincial election are invited to attend the all-candidates forum organized for their riding.


The forums will begin at 7:00 pm in the UNBC Canfor Theater and last for 1.5 hours. The doors will open 30 minutes prior to the start of the forum.


The forums will be live streamed.  Details for live streaming will be provided latter.



Seeking Your Input


Ann Duong is requesting your input.


UNBC Sustainability met with a funder called the McConnell Foundation (a private Canadian foundation that supports climate change projects) to talk about potential projects that they could fund.Among the possibilities they could fund is an Energy Co-op project that we would like the ETG's input on. Information on the application process is available from:  https://www.mcconnellfoundation.ca/apply/for-applicants/


This will be discussed at the next Energy Transition Meeting and those interested in collaborating on this potential project can contact UNBC Sustainability at sustainability@unbc.ca.



New BC Hydro Solar And Battery Rebates (also in PG EVA Newsletter)


As of July 23, 2024 you can obtain up to $5,000 rebate for solar and/or up to $5,000 rebate for batteries for residential homes.  Even more funds are available for MURBs (Mulit-Unit Residential Buildings), businesses, social housing and indigenous projects and more . . . . .  You area also permitted to combine this rebate with the Canadian Federal interest free loan – but, the federal program necessitates the energy audit, which the BC Hydro program does not require.

Keep in mind that most of us will do quite well plugging extension cords into our EVs to power the refrigerator, deep freeze, computer and other stuff during power outages – and as such, will not require the home batteries.  But, there could be added cost savings if BC Hydro permits you to also sign-up for the Time-of-Use (TOU) billing plan.


Information on the rebates  https://www.bchydro.com/powersmart/residential/rebates-programs/solar-battery.html?utm_source=direct&utm_medium=redirect&utm_content=solarrebate



New BC Hydro Rate Design Application (also in PG EVA Newsletter)


It appears BC Hydro would like to provide customers the option to sign-up to be o a flat service rate.


This would enable individuals who currently pay the higher step 2 electricity rates, as they heat with electricity, charge electric vehicles or wish to get off of natural gas, to pay less over all for their electricity.


It appears BC Hydro would like to freeze the higher Step 2 electrical rate while increasing the Step 1 rates.  I assume this would continue until the Step 1and Step 2 rates become the same, at which time they would eliminate the Step 2rate.


Among other changes . . . . which appear to make sense with respect to the ongoing energy transition.


I did not spend a lot of time reviewing –thus, please let me know if I missed something of importance.


Interesting information included in their application:


  • As of March 31, 2024, BC Hydro had about 9,000 net metering customers - customers who generate electricity for their own use (i.e.solar, wind) - with a total generation capacity of approximately 79 MW.


  • About 6,000 BC Hydro customers have signed up to be on the optional Time-of-Day Rate


https://www.bcuc.com/OurWork/ViewProceeding?applicationid=1249 (scroll down)


https://docs.bcuc.com/documents/proceedings/2024/doc_77680_b-1-bch-2024-ratedesign-application.pdf


The BCUC invites you to get involved in the review process:  https://www.bcuc.com/GetInvolved/GetInvolvedProceeding



How China Got To Dominate The Energy Transition


From 2009 to 2022, the [Chinese Government] fronted its EV automakers over $29 billion via subsidies, R&D spending and tax breaks.  It spent heavily on inflating domestic demand via consumer-side subsidies and incentives.


The Chinese Government phased out their subsidies in 2022.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rkxMdmipYqM (a very insightful 9 minute video)


Does anybody have any sense as to how much the Canadian Government, provincial governments, US Government and US state governments have provided as subsidies, R&D spending, tax breaks and rebates to consumers who purchase an EV? I believe the numbers I have seen are well in excess to $29 billion.


This Government of Canada News Release indicates:  With the $120 billion clean economy plan detailed in our 2023 budget, our government is building Canada’s clean economy and creating great careers for workers across Canada.


https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/news/2023/07/government-of-canada-delivers-on-key-climate-commitment-to-phase-out-inefficient-fossil-fuel-subsidies.html



Unpacking Fossil Fuel Subsidies In Canada


It appears as of December 11, 2020 that Governments in Canada had provided more in subsidies to the fossil fuel industry than has been provided to get us off of fossil fuels. This comes across as a weird tug-of-war.


https://www.iisd.org/articles/unpacking-canadas-fossil-fuel-subsidies-faq


Another report suggests at least $21.198 billion in subsidies were provided for fossil fuels in Canada in 2022 alone.


https://environmentaldefence.ca/federal-fossil-fuel-subsidies-tracking/


A July 2021 report credits the IEA (International Energy Agency) projecting global direct subsidies to:


  • fossil fuels will fall from US$447 billion in 2017 to US$165 billion in 2030 and to US$139 billion in 2050, as fossil fuel demand declines.


  • renewables will grow from US$166 billion in 2017 to US$209 billion in2050


https://www.canadianenergycentre.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/P-36-Research-Brief-13-FINAL.pdf



Another Subsidy Of Up To $200 Million To Coastal Gaslink


While Canada committed to phasing out subsidies for fossil fuels, recently updated financial data reveals Coastal GasLink has been granted up to $200 million in additional subsidies.


Not long before the subsidy to Coastal Gaslink, Cedar LNG was provided subsidies worth between $400 and $500 million.


https://www.nationalobserver.com/2024/07/23/news/feds-loaning-coastal-gaslink-200-million?mkt_tok=Nzc0LVNITy0yMjgAAAGUjh2mVseIr482a7Kewg6esRcP-VRneKK7kN0DVQK99lrDTkufUtTEuyCWPjEE8Ky-RVv-9Jlgfbt-JFhU6pGgLMiCWJlAI9Zs9ytvkwynwWE



The Energy Transition Is Well Underway


The International Energy Agency indicates


The world now invests almost twice as much in clean energy as it does in fossil fuels…


Investment in clean energy has accelerated since 2020, and spending on renewable power, grids and storage is now higher than total spending on oil, gas, and coal.


https://www.iea.org/reports/world-energy-investment-2024/overview-and-key-findings?mkt_tok=MTg4LVZEVS0zNjAAAAGURZLy2exXd8d8okE2vzlES5ZhYbxpFHFgGZielUG_qRMS_8wXuwMC4Mwo_XQF5NOxCTU3QAaV2udztKfqIR5X1tm2JlUxjuHWUYNYELwndvfV


A report by London-based energy think tankEmber indicates


Renewables generated a record 30% of global electricity in 2023, driven by growth in solar and wind.


This is an increase from 19% of the global electricity in 2000.



The small increase in fossil fuel generation of electricity was likely due to reduced hydro generation because of drought conditions.


Ember provides a free interactive data set for 80 or 215 countries (sorry, I did not count) https://ember-climate.org/data/data-tools/data-explorer/



Updated Provincial Scorecard


The Pembina Institute updated their provincial scorecard regarding greenhouse gas emissions that was originally completed in 2021.  Extracts from the71-page report:


We found promising signs of progress since our last report: as climate policies have taken effect, Canada’s overall emissions have begun to meaningfully decline. Nevertheless, it remains the case that some governments are still doing far less than others to take action on delivering clean, prosperous,equitable economies for their citizens.


For those governments that are currently falling behind, we hope this report will demonstrate that well-designed policies have already led to meaningful emissions reductions, and those emissions reductions have come with social, economic and environmental benefits.


Governments that do not take action today to reduce emissions in line with Canada’s international commitments are not only leaving their populations vulnerable to the most devastating impacts of climate change, they are doing a disservice to the future competitiveness of their jurisdictions and their industries in the global marketplace.


The fact that overall emissions in 2022were lower than in 2019 is a positive sign that climate policies in Canada are starting to work to reduce emissions.

Of Canada’s ten provinces, two are responsible for a majority of the country’s overall emissions: Alberta accounts for the largest share (38%), while Ontario accounts for the second largest(22%) (Figure 3).


Ontario and Quebec have the lowest emissions intensity on a per unit of GDP basis.


Saskatchewan and Alberta have the highest emissions intensity per unit of GDP and the per capita rate is more than three times greater than the Canadian average.


Change in emissions by jurisdiction in Canada from 2005 to 2022:


Even some aspects of the fossil fuel activities have seen reductions in their emissions:


BC greenhouse gas emissions as of 2022

BC’s greenhouse gas emissions increased by 3% from 2005 to 2022.


Although [BC’s] Net-Zero New Industry policy will require all proposed LNG facilities in or entering the environmental assessment process to have a credible plan to be net-zero by 2030, four of the six LNG terminals now in development are exempt.


https://www.pembina.org/sites/default/files/2024-07/All%20Together%20Now.pdf



Petition For Near Zero Methane Emissions By 2030


A peer-reviewed study in Environmental Science and Technology in 2021 found that the B.C. oil and gas sector could be emitting more than twice the amount of methane previously reported.


With this in mind, B.C.’s methane regulations must include strong measurement, monitoring, and reporting requirements to evaluate progress and to ensure that companies are taking the appropriate actions.


https://act.stand.earth/page/69816/petition/1?ea.tracking.id=email-kick&utm_campaign=canada__clim&utm_content=textlink&utm_medium=email&utm_source=email-ea&ea.url.id=2679862&forwarded=true



The Truth About Fossil Fuels


The fossil fuel industry has known as early as the 1950s that its operations would have devastating effects on the planet, but made the decision to lie to the public and cover up evidence —sowing doubt about climate science and convincing people that fossil fuels are here to stay.


Today, the fossil fuel industry continues to use its power and influence to slow down essential climate action and the inevitable switch to renewable energy — all while making life more expensive by driving up inflation, energy bills and gas prices.


Fossil fuels are by far the largest contributor to the climate crisis. Most of the harmful greenhouse gas emissions in the atmosphere are from burning coal, oil and gas.


This site provides information and makes it easier for individuals who wish to take action to help expedite the transition away from fossil fuels.

https://davidsuzuki.org/project/fossil-fuels-exposed/?mkt_tok=MTg4LVZEVS0zNjAAAAGUhDvhYImJwH0dwOY2fB7Gmy20eSidkInnDK-2EzhvJL8bILU8HnqAnF9cBU6KWkV6ojvgKNvtA31KpDqe5JnAyl7oko47n0XtbJp29h5Md5d5&utm_source=mkto-first-englishBroadcast-link-ps&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=fossilFuelsExposed-launchEmail-24jul2024



World-first: EVs Power Grid During Outage In Australia


The power supply to tens of thousands of homes was interrupted during a major storm in Canberra.


During the blackout, 16 EVs were plugged in at properties across Canberra.


The researcher claimed that immediately after the blackout, these vehicles started discharging power into the grid, as they’ve been programmed to do.


The event, which took place in February, was first real-world test of our vehicles and chargers, according to the researcher.


“It’s the first time in the world this type of vehicle-to-grid response to an emergency has been demonstrated,” said lead author of the study, Senior Research Fellow Dr Bjorn Sturmberg from the Australian National University.


https://interestingengineering.com/energy/world-first-evs-give-power-back-to-grid-during-outage?mc_cid=ab6355d23a&mc_eid=974f9ac839



DC Solar To DC Charging Your EV


This is your opportunity to reduce energy losses which occur when you convert solar electricity from DC to AC then back to DC as currently occurs.


You may be losing up to 13% of your electricity due to these conversions.


A comment from @beforebefore below the video suggests the electricity loses being noted may be over stated.  If you have insight into these loses, please inform us!


I also remember hearing that EVs require a certain minimum kWh rate if charging via DC.  If you have insight into the technicalities of charging on DC, please inform us!


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UDJFFEXqKAU(9 minute video)



Diesel Versus Battery Electric Transport Trucks


The Victoria EV Association put together this informative video comparing diesel and BEV transport trucks.


https://youtu.be/pYg_64CrgJo



Hydrogen Versus Battery Electric Transport Trucks


The Victoria EV Association put together this informative video comparing hydrogen and BEV cars and transport trucks.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NAEoprv_puI



Cost Of Transitioning From ICE To EV Medium And Heavy Trucks


If you know the trucking industry, we would appreciate your review of the cost assessment completed by transportation company Ryder System, Inc.


Of the 16.4 million Class 3-8 commercial vehicles in operation in the US, about 18,000 are already EVs.


If Ryder’s assumptions and numbers are correct, the trucking industry is looking at increases of 3% to 114% in overall costs to do the same work with EVs as compared to using ICE vehicles.


The report notes that Ryder is already helping customers successfully introduce EVs into their fleets in cases in which the customers’ transportation needs align with the technology’s current capabilities and available infrastructure.  This suggests there are already niche situations where EVs are likely saving trucking companies money.  We should see an expansion in the niche situations as more and more medium and heavy EV trucks are produced – in the same way we have seen performance improve and price decrease as the light vehicle EV market has begun to mature.


https://www.ryder.com/globalassets/media/documents/insights/white-papers/fleet-management/white-papers-ryder-ev-study_ada.pdf



Public Persuasion Episode Of The Energy Transition Show


Stephen Rader shares another episode of The Energy Transition Show.


This episode is on how you/we can be more effective at communicating about climate change in ways that will persuade people to care about climate change.


https://xenetwork.org/ets/episodes/episode-228-public-persuasion/ (1 hour 20 minute podcast)


In this regard:

1.    I need your ideas as to how the energy transition will help improve people’s lives.


2.    I would love to learn from you which messages from the PG EVA and the ETG have been effective and which messages have not been so beneficial.


Rising Insurance Costs


A shareholder advocacy organization Investors for Paris Compliance is highlighting how property and casualty insurance companies are:


  • Continuing to invest in and making money from fossil fuel


  • While passing along the increasing claims costs due to climate change on to the policy holders


  • And, while asking governments to shoulder the burden of riskier properties and climate-related infrastructure damage, potentially increasing the long-term financial load on taxpayers.


https://www.investorsforparis.com/insurance-climate-contradiction-exposed-in-new-report/?mc_cid=ab6355d23a&mc_eid=974f9ac839



Electric Plane For Flight Training


B.C.'s Sealand Flight first in Canada to use electric plane for flight training.


Sealand gets green light from Transport Canada for flight training.


Air Canada is buying 30 electric-hybrid planes and plans to use them for shorter regional flights in 2028. B.C.'s Helijet has also ordered an electric vertical takeoff and landing helicopter, and Harbour Air plans to start using electric seaplanes between Vancouver and Vancouver Island as early as 2025.


https://www.bchydro.com/news/conservation/2024/sealand-flies-electric.html?utm_source=connected&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=24-07&utm_content=plane



Improvements With Extracting Lithium From Liquids


As the electric vehicle market booms, the demand for lithium—the mineral required for lithium-ion batteries—has also soared. Global lithium production has more than tripled in the last decade. But current methods of extracting lithium from rock ores or brines are slow and come with high energy demands and environmental costs.


Researches have an improved method for extracting lithium from more dilute—and widespread—sources of the mineral, including seawater, groundwater, and "flowback water" left behind from fracking and offshore oil drilling.


Today, most lithium used in lithium batteries comes from two basic extraction processes. Lithium rock ores can be mined, smashed up with heavy machinery, and then treated with acid to isolate the lithium. Lithium brine pools, on the other hand, use massive amounts of water pumped to the earth's surface and then evaporated away — over the course of more than a year — to yield dried lithium.


[The researchers] approach isolates lithium based on its electrochemical properties, using crystal lattices of olivine iron phosphate.


https://phys.org/news/2024-06-method-optimizes-lithium-seawater-groundwater.html?mkt_tok=MTg4LVZEVS0zNjAAAAGUJqzMgC6zjKSpDHOHVWYcfcr22gOr1Hv25FnBWcmgjz-pYwJRFLWm7fjJFxJM10K0Pff6NE9Cqy14t5YPHDrKldxQyZENJm-fu-9BHDWQ9mT84wl3VngYtBk



Will Thermal Trapping Of Solar Heat Allow The Smelting Of Steel And Cooking Of Cement?


Up until now, thermal trapping had only shown that solar heat could be trapped up to 338 degrees Fahrenheit (170 degrees Celsius).


Swiss scientists are trapping ridiculously hot energy from the sun — over 1,832degrees Fahrenheit, or 1,000 degrees Celsius — by utilizing synthetic quartz.


Will this new method of thermal trapping transform the smelting and cement industries?


https://www.thecooldown.com/green-tech/solar-heat-smelting-industry-eth-zurich/?mkt_tok=MTg4LVZEVS0zNjAAAAGUJqzMgA6ZzJ6EQc8iDL_M-V1_ugQ-dP8hoWoEtKpJxlBnn2j2-I2hWgt9XWvsf8oM2O37GMdmpOFwkm4CQTKPWxD0BauZBoiFt9jWhJ7MCoY6H1mY7IEJxn0



Are EVs Really Better For The Climate?


I strongly urge you to watch this 12 minute video provided to us by Ann Duong.


This is a great video – from 1 year ago, largely reflecting upon a 2021 report.  The information contained in the video is supported by sources. 


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vi7U6Cj_2aI



Are EVs Worse For The Environment?


Ann Duong provides this 14 minute video.


This is a great video – from 5 years ago. Even better, the information contained in the video is supported by sources and is presented by an engineer. Sadly, it is interrupted by a number of advertisements.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6RhtiPefVzM



Which Pollutes More – EV Or Gas Vehicle?


Ann Duong provides this 14 minute video.


Note:  70,250,400 cars can be powered by the energy used to pump oil out of the ground in the US and offshore!!! not 19,500,000 in the video.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1oVrIHcdxjA


While I agree with the overall conclusions, and most of the magnitude - that gas vehicles emit way more pollution -, and appreciate a lot of the ‘facts’ provided, this video does not provide a balance of ‘facts’ about the pollution and loss of energy associated with the EV side of the equation.  The making of electricity does pollute, and there are electricity losses associated with the transmission and use – sadly these omissions diminish the credibility of the (correct) conclusion that EVs pollute less.



Sankey Flowchart Explained


11 minute video provided by Ann Duong explains how Sankey charts help you understand how much energy is wasted.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EVJkq4iu7bk


Transitioning from fossil energy to electric is easier than it seems.  This is because electric technologies are much more efficient than fossil technologies.  2/3rds of the fossil energy that goes in to a process is wasted. This means we do not need to produce nearly as much energy to do the same work after we have transitioned to electric technologies.



Draft Quebec Bill Would Ban PHEVs


A draft regulation, if passed, will ban the sale of light-duty internal combustion and plug-in hybrid vehicles in Quebec as of 2035.


While Quebec first announced its intention to ban new ICE vehicle sales by 2035 in 2020, a draft regulation which would make this happen has only recently been prepublished and is open for public consultation until August 25th.


“Combustion vehicles of model year 2034 and previous model years already registered in Quebec before 2035 will be able to continue to circulate and be resold,”explains the ministry spokesperson. “A used vehicle of model year 2034 or previous years could also be imported.”


https://electricautonomy.ca/policy-regulations/2024-07-17/quebec-draft-regulation-ban-ice-vehicle-sales-2035/



Gas Stations Are In Decline


While 2/3rds of Canadian residences can already charge at home, and the number of publicly accessible charging stations are increasing in number, the number of gas stations are on the decline.

https://ccentral.ca/2024-forecourt-performance-report


As of 2023, there were less than 12,000 gas stations in Canada with 1,374 gas stations located in BC.  This compares to over 26,000 publicly accessible charging stations (of which 5,252 are DCFC) in Canada, of which 5,059 are located in BC. This is not a good comparison, as most gas stations have multiple pumps,while the report appears to be counting each charge plug.  Even so, not many people can fill their gas vehicle at home.


https://natural-resources.canada.ca/energy-efficiency/transportation-alternative-fuels/resource-library/electric-vehicle-charging-infrastructure-for-canada/25756



Compensation Sought For Scuttled Keystone XL Pipeline Declined


A request by a Calgary company for compensation after its proposed Keystone XL pipeline project was scuttled was declined by the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) tribunal.


This decision may mean fossil fuel companies will not be successful in the future when they attempt to sue governments for policy changes which are made for the good of the environment or in the interest of limiting the climate change.


The trade tribunal’s decision may reduce the willingness of industry to spend time and money on long-term projects they already know are problematic.


KeystoneXL was a proposed crude oil transportation pipeline, roughly 1,900 kilometres long, which would have carried oil from the oilsands of northern Alberta to the major U.S. crude storage hub at Cushing, Oklahoma, and then on to Gulf Coast refineries.


The government of Alberta, who had agreed to invest about C$1.5 billion in equity(and a total of $8 billion in financial aid) in an effort to get the stalled Keystone XL project pipeline project moving, also has a complaint pending before the ICSID panel.  The trade tribunals decision on this matter is expected to be made in the fall.


https://www.theenergymix.com/trade-panel-tosses-15b-claim-for-keystone-compensation-in-possible-precedent-for-future-rulings/

Email Doug Beckett (ldb@pgbeckett.ca or doug.beckett@ev.princegeorge.tech) to subscribe or unsubscribe from the Energy Transition Group (ETG) Newsletter or the Prince George Electric Vehicle Association (PG EVA) Newsletter.


You are welcome to share this newsletter with others.