Robertson's Reflection
As traditional here comes my countdown of the artists who made the best opportunity of their three minutes on the Amsterdam stage in front a 1,500 Eurovision fans to impress them, and who really did not deliver any magic to help their cause before Austria next month.
Winners:
Germany - Ann Sophie with ‘Black Smoke’
Ann Sophie’s qualification route from amateur wildcard to being handed victory by default has already made her association with Eurovision a little bit fraught. Adding to that has been the issue that this was her ‘second’ song in the Contest and not the one she originally was competing with (that was ‘Jump The Gun’). Her Club Concert performance was very confident and in comparison the performance of ‘Black Smoke’ felt karaoke in the German National Final.
Now though she owns the song and it feels connected to her artistry. For me Ann Sophie now has made this her own the performance had a sense of self-security about it now that I worried would be lost after the debacle in Hannover.
Serbia - Bojana Stamenov with ‘Beauty Never Lies’
People comparing this to ‘Crisalide’ from San Marino for it’s two part structure as a negative need to step back a little. Points wise that’s still San Marino’s best ever Semi Final result and that’s without some suspect jury favoritism towards the microstate and the curse of being drawn second.
Here the mood, style and message are much more in your face on the transition than San Marino offered and it’s vital if you are doing that the crowd carry that emotion through with you. They do so by the bucketload; Eurovision fans get this and will cheer it on. This would be a good song to end the Grand Final with if that opportunity arises.
Losers:
Moldova - Eduard Romanyuta with ‘I Want Your Love’
I don’t understand this. With the dancers back Eduard looks like the sleazy pop star nobody is going to like and cast a vote for. He is good at charming an audience on stage when let loose, but to bring in the people from his National Final performance without an difference or gimmick seems a mistake to gain some positive news at the biggest preview event.
More than anybody this would have been the perfect event for Eduard to have created a little bubble of excitement by trying something new. He hasn’t done that with this performance which makes him less involved with the public than what I saw in Riga.
Poland - Monika Kuszynska with ‘In The Name Of Love’
This was drawn after Azerbaijan in Riga last week and I thought it lacked power there, but I attributed that to a great vocal from the Voice of Turkey winner. Actually Monika here lacks anything at all. There is little dynamic movement in the entire three minutes from her vocal and live this doesn’t connect deep enough to get any success. I can’t see people grabbing this story as the one tearing their hearts after coming through Azerbaijan and Cyprus and even dare I say Switzerland in that half of the draw alone.
In press interviews Monika is finding almost any opportunity to bring in her disability and, without trying to be critical of her obvious hardship, it seems very desperate. I can imagine the usually active Polish televote giving this a miss and Lithuania’s diaspora picking up 12’s instead of 10’s. Poland is now on the back foot in the pre-Contest build up.
Pictures by EBU